third kindfilm
But I Never Asked

14Narrative2025Monolith Film · HFF Munich

But I Never Asked

A young pianist at the Munich Conservatory prepares for the most important audition of her life, performing Chopin’s Ballade No. 1 – the same music broadcast by Polish radio as bombs fell on Warsaw in 1939. While perfecting her technique, Sophia becomes haunted by fragments of her family’s untold wartime past. Memories she never lived begin to surface, blurring the boundaries between history and identity, dream and reality. To truly play, she must face the traces of war passed down to her.

The film grew out of ECHOS, a memory project by Nicole Humiński and Nikolai Huber with the Deutsch-Polnische Gesellschaft München, in which descendants of Polish forced labourers speak about what was passed on to them – and what was not.

Format
Fiction short · 19 min · DCP · 5.1
Credits
  • Written & directed by Nicole Humiński
  • Cinematography Nikolai Huber
  • Editing Nicole Humiński, Nikolai Huber
  • Colour grading Nikolai Huber
  • Cast Joanna Sielicka, Jaymes Butler, Barbara Horvath
  • Production Monolith Film in cooperation with the HFF Munich
Recognition
  • PÖFF Shorts, Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival 2025 – premiere
  • 2ANNAS International Short Film Festival Riga 2026 – official selection
  • Moabinale Berlin 2026
  • BOO International Short Film Festival Prague 2026 – European BOO competition
  • EUROPIA Conference, Bamberg
But I Never Asked — 1
But I Never Asked — 2
But I Never Asked — 3
But I Never Asked — 4
But I Never Asked — 5
But I Never Asked — 6
But I Never Asked — 7
1 / 7